
Arlo SoHo
Best for social, nightlife-forward stays and easy access to SoHo, Tribeca and Lower Manhattan dining and bars.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Arlo SoHo is a modern, downtown Manhattan hotel with lively rooftop bars and multiple on-site dining spots; read this if you want a social, design-forward stay in SoHo/Hudson Square. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a classic Upper East Side luxury property with old‑New‑York prestige; read this if you want traditional service, proximity to museums, and a formal luxury experience.
Updated · about 5 km apart

Best for social, nightlife-forward stays and easy access to SoHo, Tribeca and Lower Manhattan dining and bars.

Best for travelers who prioritize classic, formal luxury, museum access and a storied New York hotel experience.
When Arlo SoHo wins: Choose Arlo SoHo if you want a younger, more social atmosphere with multiple casual dining and bar venues (including a rooftop), easy access to Lower Manhattan neighborhoods, and event/rooftop spaces for groups.
When The Carlyle wins: Choose The Carlyle if you want a quieter, traditional luxury stay on the Upper East Side with full‑service concierge, a recognized full‑service spa, and immediate access to Central Park and the Met.
Bottom line: These two Manhattan hotels serve different needs — Arlo SoHo for downtown energy and social dining/drinking; The Carlyle for classic, museum‑adjacent luxury and heritage. Pick based on neighborhood and the kind of atmosphere you prefer.
| Category | Arlo SoHo | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, social, design-forward downtown hotel with multiple bars and casual dining | Classic, formal Upper East Side luxury with an old‑New‑York reputation |
| Location | 231 Hudson Street — Hudson Square/SoHo/Tribeca border, Lower Manhattan | 35 E 76th St — Upper East Side, steps from Madison Ave, near Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | About 322–325 rooms (multiple published listings) | 188 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Opened / age | Built 2016 (recent) | Not published |
| Pool | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Lindens (Modern American), Foxtail (speakeasy), ART SoHo (rooftop), SoHo Bodega (24‑hour grab & go), Library and Courtyard bars | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge including Bemelman's Bar and 24‑hour room service (supplier listing) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; partner gym access (Gotham Gym) and Alo Moves included via Urban Fee | Full‑service spa and health club (supplier listing) |
| Known for | Rooftop nightlife, event/rooftop capacity for weddings and social events, neighborhood dining scene | Historic reputation, proximity to Central Park and major museums (Met), formal luxury service |
| Family & pets | Family friendly; pets allowed (up to two dogs/cats under 75 lbs; $20 per pet/night) | Not published |
| Accessibility & service | 24‑hour front desk, express check-in/out, luggage storage, coworking and business center | 24‑hour front desk, concierge, valet parking (surcharge), multilingual staff |
Arlo SoHo sits at 231 Hudson Street on the edge of SoHo, Tribeca and the West Village, ideal for exploring Lower Manhattan.
Best if you want Lower Manhattan neighborhoods and evening social scenes on foot.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue and a short walk from Central Park and major museums.
Best if you want museum access, Central Park, and a quieter, formal neighborhood.
Arlo SoHo offers many compact, contemporary rooms and several suites geared to modern travelers.
Rooms are practical and modern; expect compact layouts and urban design touches.
The Carlyle lists a wide range of room types and many suites, reflecting a traditional luxury inventory.
Rooms and suites follow a conventional luxury layout with formal amenities and larger suite options.
Arlo SoHo centers its public life on several casual-to-cocktail venues and a lively rooftop.
Choose Arlo for varied, casual-to-hip food and drink options concentrated on site.
The Carlyle offers formal dining consistent with its classic luxury positioning and a noted bar/lounge.
Choose The Carlyle for traditional, formal dining and an iconic hotel bar experience.
Arlo SoHo highlights event spaces and an 11th‑floor rooftop used for private events and social programming.
Arlo stands out for rooftop programming and flexible event spaces in a downtown setting.
The Carlyle emphasizes traditional luxury services including a full‑service spa and limousine/town car options.
The Carlyle’s signature strength is full‑service luxury and concierge-driven guest support.
Arlo SoHo pairs partner gym access with an active rooftop nightlife calendar.
Arlo is better if you want rooftop nightlife plus partner fitness options rather than structured on-site wellness.
The Carlyle lists a full‑service spa and a more subdued, formal nightlife offering.
The Carlyle suits travelers seeking on-site spa services and quieter evenings in a refined setting.

Arlo SoHo — ART SoHo rooftop and Foxtail speakeasy give you multiple lively evening options on property.

The Carlyle — steps from Madison Ave, a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Arlo SoHo — multiple event spaces including a rooftop with large reception capacity make it a flexible events hotel.

The Carlyle — traditional luxury service, full‑service spa, and formal dining suit guests seeking a historic luxury stay.
Arlo SoHo — it has a rooftop bar (ART SoHo), a speakeasy (Foxtail), and multiple casual bars and evening programs on site.
The Carlyle — it's located on the Upper East Side within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Arlo SoHo does not have a pool or on-site spa. The Carlyle lists a full‑service spa; the supplier listing does not publish a pool.
Both accept families. Arlo SoHo markets itself as family friendly (primary guest must be 21+ at check-in). The Carlyle is not adults‑only.
Explore how Arlo SoHo stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·