
Arlo SoHo
Best for social downtown nights, multiple on-site bars, and budget-conscious design travelers who want a lively neighborhood base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Arlo SoHo is a lively, all-ages Lower Manhattan hotel with compact rooms, multiple bars and a popular rooftop — good for social, design-minded travelers on a midrange budget. The New York EDITION is a design-forward, 5-star luxury hotel steps from Madison Square Park — read this if you want a more elevated, service-focused stay in Midtown South.
Updated · about 1.3 km apart

Best for social downtown nights, multiple on-site bars, and budget-conscious design travelers who want a lively neighborhood base.

Best for travelers who prioritize design-forward luxury rooms, dedicated service, and a central Flatiron/Madison Square Park location.
When Arlo SoHo wins: choose Arlo if you want a younger, buzzy downtown scene with multiple on-site bars and restaurants, a rooftop with skyline views, flexible event spaces, and lower-rate, compact rooms.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION for a true 5-star, design-focused hotel experience near Madison Square Park with larger luxury rooms, more formal service, and on-site spa/treatment offerings.
Bottom line: pick Arlo SoHo for social energy and neighborhood value in Lower Manhattan; pick The New York EDITION if you want full luxury, refined design, and closer access to Flatiron/Madison Square Park.
| Category | Arlo SoHo | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, neighborhood-forward, social bars and rooftop focus | Quietly luxurious, design-forward, upscale service |
| Location (neighborhood) | Hudson Square — borders SoHo, Tribeca, West Village | Madison Square Park / Flatiron, Midtown South |
| Size (rooms) | Approximately 322–325 rooms | 271 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary check-in guest must be 21+ | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site outlets: Lindens (restaurant), Foxtail (speakeasy), ART SoHo (rooftop), SoHo Bodega (24-hr) | The Clocktower restaurant; 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; partner gym access (Gotham Gym) and Alo Moves via Urban Fee | Spa treatment room(s) and on-site spa services |
| Known for | Rooftop bar with skyline views and multiple social venues | Design-forward 5-star hotel steps from Madison Square Park |
| Event space | Many flexible event spaces including a 3,000 sq ft rooftop (A.R.T. SoHo) and ten meeting/event venues | Conference space ~2100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family features | Family friendly; pet policy allows dogs and cats; wheelchair-accessible paths in some areas | Accessible rooms/options listed; pet policy and family details not fully published in supplier listing |
Arlo SoHo sits in Hudson Square on the edge of SoHo, Tribeca and the West Village — a downtown base for exploring Lower Manhattan.
Arlo puts you in a social, downtown neighborhood ideal for exploring SoHo and Tribeca on foot.
The New York EDITION is located on Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron area.
The EDITION is better if you want to be based near Madison Square Park and the Flatiron district.
Arlo SoHo’s rooms are compact and efficiently designed; room types include small 'Room' and bunk options plus a Suite (Arlo).
Choose Arlo for practical, smaller rooms and social common areas rather than large in-room living space.
The New York EDITION offers larger, 5-star rooms and multiple suite types named for views and layouts.
The EDITION is the choice for guests who prioritize spacious, design-led rooms and suite options.
Arlo SoHo centers on multiple casual and late-night venues across the building.
Arlo is a destination for on-site bars and casual dining with a local, social feel.
The New York EDITION provides a single signature restaurant and multiple bars for a refined dining experience.
The EDITION offers fewer, more formal dining outlets designed to match its 5-star positioning.
Arlo SoHo’s signature amenity is its social rooftop and multiple drinks venues rather than a pool.
Arlo’s rooftop is the main draw for views and social hours — not a pool-based resort experience.
The New York EDITION’s public highlights focus on hotel design, bars and spa treatment rooms rather than a pool.
The EDITION emphasizes in-room comfort and spa treatments; pool status is not published.
Arlo mixes partner fitness access with nightlife-oriented venues.
Arlo is for guests who want partner gym options plus an active evening scene.
The New York EDITION leans toward private wellness treatments and calmer, refined nightlife.
The EDITION suits guests who prefer in-hotel wellness services and lower-key bars.

Arlo SoHo — multiple on-site bars and an 11th-floor rooftop with skyline views.

The New York EDITION — luxury rooms and several named suites close to Madison Square Park.

Arlo SoHo — many event spaces including a large rooftop and several studio/meeting rooms.

The New York EDITION — 5-star service, concierge, spa treatment rooms and formal dining.
Arlo SoHo has a stronger nightlife focus with multiple bars, live jazz at Foxtail, and an active rooftop; The New York EDITION has quieter, more formal bars.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatment rooms and on-site spa services. Arlo SoHo does not have an on-site spa and does not have a swimming pool.
Both properties welcome guests of all ages. Arlo SoHo requires the primary check-in guest to be 21 or older; The New York EDITION is not adults-only.
The New York EDITION is steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building; Arlo SoHo is downtown in Hudson Square and requires a short walk or subway ride to reach that area.
Explore how Arlo SoHo stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·