
Arlo SoHo
Best for social, food-and-drink–centric stays and guests who want easy access to SoHo/Tribeca nightlife.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Arlo SoHo is a lively, design-forward downtown hotel with multiple bars and a popular rooftop—good for social travelers who want casual New York neighborhoods. The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York is a classic Fifth Avenue luxury property beside Central Park—readers who want formal, old-world service and park views should consider it.
Updated · about 5.5 km apart

Best for social, food-and-drink–centric stays and guests who want easy access to SoHo/Tribeca nightlife.

Best for travelers wanting traditional Fifth Avenue luxury, attentive service, and suites with park views.
When Arlo SoHo wins: pick Arlo SoHo if you want a younger, neighborhood-focused stay with multiple in-house bars, a busy rooftop, and flexible event spaces—good for groups, informal nights out, and exploring Lower Manhattan on foot or by Citi Bike.
When The Pierre wins: choose The Pierre if you value a historic, formal setting on Fifth Avenue steps from Central Park, expect high-touch service and larger suites, or need a quieter, upscale base for museums and Midtown attractions.
Bottom line: both hotels deliver clear New York character. Arlo SoHo leans casual and social in Lower Manhattan; The Pierre delivers classic Fifth Avenue luxury and parkside elegance.
| Category | Arlo SoHo | The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, social, neighborhood-focused | Formal, historic, classic luxury |
| Location | Hudson Square / SoHo border—close to Canal Street and West Village | Fifth Avenue beside Central Park and Madison Avenue |
| Size (rooms) | About 322–325 rooms | 189 rooms |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcomed; primary guest must be 21+ to check in | All ages welcomed; family friendly (children policy varies by rate) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues (Lindens, Foxtail, ART SoHo rooftop, Library, SoHo Bodega) | Perrine (fine-dining) plus 1 bar/lounge and room service |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; partner gym access (Gotham Gym) | Spa services on site; 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Rooftop views, food & drink venues, event spaces for lively gatherings | Historic Fifth Avenue address, Central Park proximity, traditional luxury |
| Parking & transfers | No on-site parking; nearby self-park garages; no valet | Self parking (surcharge) and roundtrip airport shuttle (surcharge) |
Arlo SoHo sits at 231 Hudson Street in Hudson Square, bordering SoHo, Tribeca and the West Village.
Choose Arlo SoHo for a downtown, walkable base focused on SoHo/Tribeca.
The Pierre is on Fifth Avenue at East 61st Street, directly across from Central Park.
Choose The Pierre for classic Midtown access and immediate Central Park proximity.
Arlo SoHo offers many compact, design-led rooms and a small number of suites geared to urban travelers.
Arlo’s rooms are practical and social—best for short stays and guests focused on the neighborhood.
The Pierre’s inventory skews toward larger classic rooms and many named suites for more formal stays.
The Pierre suits travelers who prioritize spacious rooms or suites and traditional luxury touches.
Arlo SoHo centers its guest experience on multiple, varied food-and-drink venues.
Arlo is better if you want many in-house, informal dining and drinking options and a rooftop scene.
The Pierre offers formal dining at Perrine plus a single bar/lounge and limited room service hours.
The Pierre is aimed at classic, upscale dining rather than a cluster of casual bars.
Arlo SoHo’s signature draw is its social spaces—especially the ART SoHo rooftop and Foxtail speakeasy.
If rooftop drinks and a nightlife-friendly hotel are priorities, Arlo SoHo fits better.
The Pierre’s signature is its Fifth Avenue presence and park-facing rooms that feel formal and refined.
The Pierre’s appeal is its location and old-world service rather than a party atmosphere.
Arlo SoHo supports active guests through partner services rather than an on-site spa.
Arlo suits active, nightlife-oriented travelers who are comfortable using partner facilities.
The Pierre provides in-house spa services and 24-hour fitness facilities for a more self-contained wellness stay.
Choose The Pierre when you want in-house spa and fitness amenities and a quieter evening vibe.

Arlo SoHo — multiple bars including ART SoHo rooftop and the Foxtail speakeasy make it the easier pick for evenings on-site.

The Pierre — formal rooms, park views, and a historic Fifth Avenue address fit travelers seeking traditional luxury.

Arlo SoHo — many event venues including a large rooftop and several studios for varied group sizes.

The Pierre — a wide selection of named suites and Park View rooms for guests prioritizing space and outlook.
Arlo SoHo — it has a dedicated rooftop (ART SoHo), a speakeasy (Foxtail), and multiple casual bars on-site.
The Pierre — it sits on Fifth Avenue beside Central Park, making park access immediate.
Arlo SoHo has no on-site pool or spa and uses partner gym access; The Pierre lists spa services on site but pool availability is not published.
Both accept families. Arlo SoHo requires the primary guest checking in to be 21 or older; The Pierre allows children and notes small-children policies in its booking details.
Explore how Arlo SoHo stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·